Answer: NO. I have both, but have more of the Forester seaters. Your comments are laughable and many have seen the groups I shoot. Sorry your skills dont stack up. I'm going to upgrade my dies for two rifles and am undecided which die manufacturer to go with. Either a bushing change or collet die can control this. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Both are top quality dies. I will likely get the Redding and use those until the whidden custom set is finished(8-10 weeks) if the Redding set does not work so well. As the neck enters the bushing the bushing applies a predetermined amount of tension on the neck. I should have been more clear in my OP. I will say right now Forster FL dies using a mandrel to set inside neck tension with Redding Mic seaters are my favorite combo . When this action occurs the inconsistencies of the case neck wall are forced back to the outside of the neck case. See our custom dies. Thanks guys, I didn't realize the expander ball would cause issues with run out. Subtract .002 from the diameter you measure to select the bushing size. I'm not 100% sure about what dies will do the best job for what I intend to do. Click Here for Reloading Die Instructions. I've got both. So now, which is best? JavaScript is disabled. I will likely get the Redding and use those until the whidden custom set is finished(8-10 weeks) if the Redding set does not work so well. Would like come comments/input to make the right choice the. I'm waiting to make a judgment on Whidden dies until I receive the custom die back. I use the Redding Type S FL bushing die, Redding shell holder, and Redding Competition Bullet Seating Die and am extremely pleased with them. Looks like its time to step up to some Whidden dies and a T7 or Zero press! Dillon Powder Die for RL 450 RL 550 XL 650. 076-60387 | Redding. I'm planning on Whidden hydroform dies, however not decided on anything else for the reloading dies. I set up for a tiny shoulder bump-- just enough that the bolt closes easy. But hey thats just me. You can tell the machining differences and quality when you use both. Not sure why. I was eyeing the Forster with micrometer but my local shop is out of stock for another 5 weeks. The way I approached it was to find out the reamer specs (or alternatively measure fired brass) to get a sense of a starting point that I should be looking for. If you want maximum precision for your favorite rounds including many wildcat rounds you need the tools we build into each one. Do you have a reamer print or know anything about the chamber reamer dimensions? Access from your Country was disabled by the administrator. Is there a specific caliber or do you mean all Lapua brass? Home; . Replacement Decap Assembly Item #WHIDDCA21308. In reality, over the coarse of brass life, the properties of brass change, and the gripping power of the necks will be the first indicator. I also use the Hornady LNL progressive for my competition which is .308 Win, F-Class Mid Range (500-600 yards). The offered me the Whidden at a slight discount (but still a tad more than the Forster). I then bought a RCBS FL sizer and havent had an issue since. In determining neck tension with the non-bushing sizer die, simply change the expander ball size to obtain the desired amount of tension. Full length sizer dies can be broken down into two types. The diameter of the expander ball will determine the neck tension. Using my Hornady concentricity gauge I sampled each batch of 20 and runout was 1/2 thousandth in each direction. I get that they would all serve me very well and Im splitting hairs for differences but Im still curious to see what youd go with and why. I can only guess that maybe this is an early production. 4. ablnx 2 yr. ago. If you don't like Redding, you really won't like Whidden.. my last set was a polished turd that failed to go through polishing. I like the die a lot, it does what it's supposed to very well. With this method the amount of neck tension is determined by the size of the bushing as it is the only and last area of the die to be in contact with the neck of the case. I have redding type s and Redding competition and theyve been great. A good set of bushing dies allow more control. The seating die that comes with the collet die set is a dead length bullet seater which I find is the best seater that comes with standard die set. Really enjoy using the competition bullet seating die with the micrometer, which has sped up my reloading process. I have sent several full length dies into both Redding and Forster to have to neck lapped to the dimension I want. I ordered a FL Bushing set for my 300 PRC. Appreciate Leadburner's feedback. The bushing sizer die allows more flexibility in the amount of neck sizing. Redding 6.5 Creedmoor Premium Deluxe Set - The Runner-Up. I do not neck turn, and I do not want to neck turn which is why I use Forster FL sizing dies. The Whidden Bushing Sizer allows the flexibility of neck tension should a different thickness in the neck of the brass occur from one manufacturer to another. and our Reloading and tunin. I also use Forsters Full length non bushing dies with great success, you can send them in or order from them and for a very small fee they will hone the neck to you desired size. popcorn is popping, can you two provide live commentary during mcgregor/mayweather? I'm indecisive about what die set to go with to get the best performance? Redding for everything other than the Lee Universal decapper. You are using an out of date browser. I would advise against the whidden seating dies simply for the goofy nylon insert they use to seat the bullet. These will be for a 7mm STW and a 260 Remington. Redding type S Fl sizing bushing die. I like the Redding S sizer dies and the Forster micrometer seating dies. In Stock. You can send them a print of your reamer and they will deliver a die set that matches your specific chamber dimensions and they cost about the same as a Redding type S set. What Milo says is true, the brass changes because it flows forward and the neck gradually thickens which leads to an increase in neck tension. JavaScript is disabled. These will be for a 7mm STW and a 260 Remington. You are using an out of date browser. No bushing is included with the set. That being saidif there were anything else available in that cartridge Id save the $. Either can work best. $276.97. No products in the cart. The pin was not bent so the decapping rod appears to have been bent from the factory. For this example, a .268 Bushing would be a good starting point to obtain about .001 neck tension. Just did the powder dispenser as a separate step. The donor rifle is a Ruger 77, round top, tang safety. In any case I believe you will need custom dies if your cartridge is the 270 AI then all should be do a great job. Looking for a set of dies for 6.5 creedmoor and wondering which premium die set I should go with. Today I shot a .1150 group with Redding match dies and I was a bit shaky. " Ended up taking the gauge back to Cabela's as there was no need for it. This increase, however, is slow and gradual and the .001" increment in bushing size is too coarse to control it. We offer Custom Sizers, Seaters, Hydraulic Form Dies and Trim Dies from .20 Caliber to .408. In Stock. This really cuts down on case neck run-out. With the exception of the Whidden inline dies. No issues with either. You are using an out of date browser. All of our standard sizer dies include a shoulder datum collar (shoulder bump gauge) to measure shoulder bump and headspace. 2023 Whidden Gunworks All Rights Reserved, Click Adjustable Sizer & Micrometer Seater Set. Some dies, mostly non bushing dies, overwork the brass causing it to be work hardened, you cant control neck tension with a non bushing die, using an expander ball is not great for runout. I have an induction annealer and a hydraulic pressure gauge on my press. I like Redding and Whidden bushing dies but will stick to Redding if I have a choice. I was getting terrible runout from both Redding and Whidden bushing dies in 2 different calibers with Lapua fireformed brass that was annealed. They also include a pin retainer should you chose to use your sizer without the expander. That is not setting neck tension with the die. 4. I have 5 Whidden sizer dies and about 10 to 12 sets of Redding dies. Topic Icons: Not Replied Replied Active Hot Sticky Unapproved Solved Private Closed. I've never tried a Forster FL die but would be tempted to have them hone the neck for a specific neck tension and try it out. I prefer to full length size every time and Forster does not make such a die that will FL size and control neck tension. I have a 280 AI being built to the traditional chamber so Im going to have them build me a set once I get my hands on the rifle. Building the rifle on a Ruger 77 ts, 26 in (1-8) Lilja barrel, pillar bedding, some trigger work. In general, what is your preference in die manufacturer for higher end reloading dies and why? Forster honed necks hands down for best runout. 2023 Whidden Gunworks All Rights Reserved. However, the non-bushing sizer die uses an expander ball to size the neck of the case. It may not display this or other websites correctly. Wilson bushings. Popcorn is popping, can you two provide live commentary during McGregor/Mayweather? If for some unforeseen reason we are out of stock of a caliber die, you the customer, will be notified within 24 business hours of the order being . $710. The depth increments are easily read and will stay that way for years of use. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Scan this QR code to download the app now. Our Custom dies will solve problems such as sticky extraction and the dreaded "Bolt click" without over . Trustpilot. Im running a t7 and Redding dies exclusively (minus a custom set of Hornady) and I will say that I wish my Hornady were Redding. Always remember, windage and elevation!". I, however, would not be able to identify a die issue if I had one that was causing runout. This really depends on the bushing/expander relationship. 3. For more information, please see our Honed Forster FL dies gives me the least runout. I sent them 3 or 4 pieces of brass and the old sizer and they are making me a custom die. Furman are you sizing with a bushing die only then? Doesnt seem to hurt accuracy as it shoots as well as I can shoot it that particular day. I do like the Forster option of the Forster bushing die with three bushings its like hitting the easy button to me as theyve always been right what I needed without having to source the bushings separately which I like or wait till I get brass to load a round. forum.accurateshooter.com/threads/cost-of-redding-vs-whidden-dies.3963683/, Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; Intel Mac OS X 10_15_7) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML, like Gecko) Chrome/103.0.0.0 Safari/537.36. Obviously to obtain more neck tension a smaller size bushing would be needed. Everyone seems to talk about overworking their brass. Most over-resize the front portion of the case near the shoulder, and don't resize the base of the case enough, if at all. I use a lot of bushing dies with great success. Whidden Click Adj Fl Bushing Sizer Die As handloaders have become more aware of shoulder bump and proper adjustment of the sizer die in recent years, there has become a . Would that make a bushing set pointless? Whidden Gunworks White Oak Armament Wilson Inc. Shop all within Wilson Inc. . It's really a toss-up. That is setting neck tension with a separate part(mandrel) and a separate operation. The bushing size is dependent on case neck thickness and bullet diameter, not the chamber of the rifle. I have had a set of Forster National Match 308 dies and I still have the set of forser 223 dies. The quality and outcome is far superior to anything else I have tried. My experience isn't complete with them yet. .300blk set for subsonic and set for supersonic with 155gr boolit.) Quite often we hear the question What is the difference between a bushing full length sizer die and a non-bushing full length sizer die and which is best?. I like Whidden dies. It is not advised. I prefer them over my Whidden Seating dies. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. We have 6.5 PRC dies for sale, from great brands like Forster, Hornady, Lee, Lyman, RCBS, and Redding Reloading Products. The beauty of the progressive press is one completed round with every stroke. I had a custom made from my fired brass for my 300norma, as chamber is slightly different then samii. I could always use the Redding for SCAR 17 if I eventually decided to go with the custom whidden set. Our Custom dies will solve problems such as sticky extraction and the dreaded Bolt click without over working your brass. JavaScript is disabled. Is there a difference in accuracy downrange shooting ammo that say has .007-.010 runout from a bushing die vs say a honed FL sizing die that produces runout between .0005-.001 consistently? Presently building a .270 Ackley Improved. We can use a reamer print to produce the dies however, if the dies are manufactured and are not compatible with your rifles chamber, Whidden Gunworks will not be responsible for replacement dies or refund. These two die types are not to be confused as being interchangeable. Thoughts? I have way more Forster ultra micrometer and theyve all been great as well. Our hand-polished sizer die has a shorter OAL for better shoulder bump-back, a smaller base, and tighter internal tolerances. I personally own and use a set of Whidden dies, and I am very, very impressed with them. Pretty minimal sizing-- I had 2200-2300 rounds through my .260 barrel when I decided to swap to 6.5 SAUM. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Who made the reamer? It may not display this or other websites correctly. Short Action Customs Sizing & Seating Dies - Evaluation & Discussion, Alpha Class Long Range Scope Review - TT, ZCO, Schmidt, March, Vortex, Doug from Camera Land's Day 2 SHOT Show Report, Camera Land is Prepping for Year End Sales. 13095 450th Ave. Bellevue, IA 52031. To ease case neck entry into the bushing, all bushings have a small radius on the inside edge. With no preference on either, these types include the bushing sizer die and the non-bushing sizer die. Necks are not overworked, and neck diameters are consistent to within .0005. Once you pass about 600yds or so if everything isn't in order you'll know about it pretty quickly. My cases come out of the die with zero run out. Anneal, everytiime. This is similar to a Wilson hand die with micrometer top. I've have both Whidden & Redding but in different calibers. The dies are reasonably priced too and there Micro Seating dies work great too. I'm disappointed in quality/control of the whiddens and also the seating stem on the micro seater. We also made a video on this subject that you can, Whidden Gunworks manufactures custom dies for you to match your exact specifications for .20 Caliber and larger. Hand charge powder using Fx120i and V3 auto trickler; +/- .02 grains. Custom dies are best made using three pieces of fired brass from your rifles chamber. Some smiths flat out told me that I was making a mistake going with the Ruger, others simply wanted to sell me a custom or blueprinted Remington action, others told me that they get a whole lot more money to do the build because Rugers required special tooling to work on them. I run a separate expander mandrel die, for context. 5. You can anneal more or less to control neck hardness and maintain the same seating pressure. I have the Redding Competition dies for my .22-250 AI and they work great. The Power-Pac linkage and solid steel arm multiplies the leverage you apply to the handle, making is easier to size cases and reduces fatigue more. The sizer will accept Redding or L.E. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, which supports our community. Neck dies are not meant to bump the shoulder. The Redding competition dies are very good but my favorite is the Wilson chamber die. Im pretty much running Whidden for everything now. What decapping pin is appropriate for small primer lapua brass with the small flash holes? Other JLC Precision Products. Proponents of them say that the floating bushing is supposed to allow the case to self center, thus improve concentricity? For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. We also made a video on this subject that you can check out here. Redding 6.5mm Creedmoor Competition Bushing Neck Die Set - The Best Budget Option. In those circumstances we can use your reamer print but please note the fired brass will usually yield the best results. This build started taking life last June or July. Whether youre a hunter or a competition shooter Whidden Gunworks can manufacture Custom dies to your exact specifications and if needed can work with your gunsmith to ensure your dies are as accurate as your new rifle. I have other Redding sizing dies (non-competition) where the decapping pin scribes a circle if you rotate it in your hand. NOTE: Measuring several loaded rounds and using the average is advisable. Forum Icons: Forum contains no unread posts Forum contains unread posts. I have some loads that I have been able to achieve my lowest runout values and most consistent neck tension by using an expander. I want recommend that you check the purchase price. The bushing sizer die uses a bushing to aid in the sizing of the neck while the body of the die does the sizing of the case body. Send a reamer print to the die companies and see if their die will match up with your chamber. Redding did decent for me, but would prefer Forster as a first choice. How many do you want me to post? I have shot .090 groups with lee dies and .30 caliber bullets and I have shot .065 groups with .284 bullets and RCBS X dies. I use nothing but the Redding dies for my competition rifle. Your gunsmith can give you a copy if you do not have it. I use nothing but the Redding dies for my competition rifle. Redding makes the best body dies and competition shell holders. Yikes! We have found the best method to make Custom dies is to use your firedbrass from the rifles chamber. Remove case to trim and hand prime via Sinclair Hand Priming tool. Two-die set, FL Sizer and Micrometer-top Seater, costs $184.99. Runout was measured on a 21st Century Concentricity gauge. I bought Redding to start but ran into major issues with the FL sizer denting the shoulder of the brass. 076-66387 | Redding. The non-bushing sizer die typically yields more concentric ammo in our experience.